Over at The Good Raised Up, Liz Opp wrote about her yearly meeting and noted this: "One Friend commented with some disgust that he had once seen a sign at a Liberal Friends' event saying, "You can b…

Over at The Good Raised Up, Liz Opp wrote about her yearly meeting and noted this:

"One Friend commented with some disgust that he had once seen a sign at a Liberal Friends' event saying, "You can believe whatever you want." The Friend went on to testify that being a Quaker isn't about believing what you want. It's about living your life by following the leadings of the Spirit. "

As a seeker this interests me for a couple of reasons.
One reason is that I'm trying to live my life by following the light within, or the leading of the spirit or whatever you prefer to call that source of undeniable instruction.
I am certainly not the first to ever notice that this light does not always instruct me to do what I would personally prefer to do. Often quite the opposite. I attribute this to the Inner Guide being a whole lot smarter than me.

The other reason is that to me following the light and "believing whatever you want" are NOT mutually exclusive.

Following your inner leading seems to me a solid thing...you hear and you heed.

What you "believe" is just a story you tell yourself.

An example of this is me, Plain Dress, and the rest of the world.

The light/leading part of this is that in 2007 I began to feel strongly led to change my way of dressing, my way of presenting myself to the world, my way of purchasing clothing, and so on. All of this is a simple matter of hearing and heeding.

The belief part of this is very much up to interpretation.

I can believe G-d has called me to Plain Dress.
I can believe I am called to Plain Dress as witness of Christian Modesty.
I can believe I am called to Plain Dress as a testimony against the idiocy of the fashion industry.
I can believe I am called to Plain Dress as an example of greater justice in a world of underpaid sweatshop workers.
I can believe I thought up dressing plain all on my own as an excuse to make a bunch of new dresses.

Basically, I can believe whatever I want.

Other people can believe about me whatever they want.

Beliefs, however compelling they may be, can't be proved or disproved.

A great strength of Quakerdom is the realization that there is that of God in everyone, even in people who are quite different in one way or another.

A weakness it is easy to slide into is interpreting this as "I can see that of God in people based on how much they agree with me and see things just the way I see them".

God seems somehow to have created billions and billions of people, each with a separate set of life experiences, each with an individual point of view.

This makes it unlikely that anyone on the planet will see anything exactly the way I see it.

But that's ok, I'm not the boss of the world. They can believe what they want.

Of course, you don't have to believe that.

Views: 59

Comment by Forrest Curo on 8th mo. 11, 2010 at 1:00pm
Well, no, you can't "believe what you like." You can believe what you do believe...

You can examine beliefs and whether you consider any set of them justified or unjustified.

You can strive for loyalty to a belief, to "keep the faith," etc.-- but ultimately, you know whether whistling past a graveyard means that you like to whistle, or means something else about you.

A better way to word a prevalent Quaker position on all this might be: "We strive to include anyone of honest good will, regardless of what beliefs he will or won't cop to."

Is this good or bad? Yes! It drives me a little nuts too, from time to time, offering as it does some justice, plus a certain spurious rightness and some clear inconvenience.

Does Jesus welcome atheists? Well of course. But then what?
Comment by Leslie Rodgers on 8th mo. 11, 2010 at 6:22pm
Good point--you believe what you CAN believe. I must admit I haven't always "liked" some of the things I've believed.
My companion dilemma is that I find I'm unable to Make myself believe something I just Can't believe, even if believing it would make me fit in better with a particular group.

Belief carries me just so far in my relationships with assorted religious folk. Where my ability to believe comes to a screeching halt my faith generally steps in to ease the way.

So far, so good.


I do like your way of stating the Quaker position, it is clearer

Comment

You need to be a member of QuakerQuaker to add comments!

Join QuakerQuaker

Support Us

Did you know that QuakerQuaker is 100% reader supported? If you think this kind of outreach and conversation is important, please support it with a monthly subscription or one-time gift.


You can also make a one-time donation.

Latest Activity

Kirby Urner posted a video

New England Transcendentalism: Bringing It Forward

The history of American literature includes the philosophy, and futurism, of R. Buckminster Fuller. Given our historical framework, let's give that philosoph...
5 hours ago
William F Rushby replied to William F Rushby's discussion 'Recapturing Initiative for Conservative Friends'
"Wow, Marcia!  Your email is packed with issues we could discuss.  I am still laboring…"
9th month 2
Marcia P Roberts replied to William F Rushby's discussion 'Recapturing Initiative for Conservative Friends'
"I am curious to know what rituals Conservative Friends hold dear, William, when you talk about…"
9th month 2
Scott MacLeod liked Laura Rediehs's profile
8th month 26
William F Rushby replied to William F Rushby's discussion 'Recapturing Initiative for Conservative Friends'
8th month 23
Keith Saylor replied to William F Rushby's discussion 'Recapturing Initiative for Conservative Friends'
""The evidence suggests that Friends need the counsel of one another to implement their…"
8th month 23
William F Rushby replied to William F Rushby's discussion 'Recapturing Initiative for Conservative Friends'
"Howard, I think you would be above such stuff!"
8th month 22
Howard Brod replied to William F Rushby's discussion 'Recapturing Initiative for Conservative Friends'
"Thanks William. I have heard of what you speak of.  It is sad. Thanks."
8th month 22

© 2020   Created by QuakerQuaker.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service