Chris Hedges Writes a Stinging Critique of the Idea of Progress

Greetings:

In a previous blog post on Progressive Quakers I noted that the progressives were fully immersed in the idea of progress; that things will inevitably get better and better.  And it was this idea of progress which allowed the progressives to undermine traditional Quaker Faith and Practice so effectively.  It was also this idea of progress which provided them with conceptual tools for their support of W.W. I.  Chuck Fager in his two books on Progressive Quakers seems to agree with this primary view of how history is working.

At truthdig Chris Hedges has penned a stinging, and at the same time thoughtful, critique of the idea of progress and how it negatively impacts our world.  The article can be found here:

http://www.truthdig.com/report/item/our_mania_for_hope_is_a_curse_2...

I found the essay helpful and insightful.  Perhaps you will as well,

Jim

Views: 290

Comment by Forrest Curo on 5th mo. 27, 2015 at 12:52pm

CH generally writes eloquent rants; but I wonder how much of your enthusiasm with this one is due to approval of his conclusion...?

Truly, faith in technology is a blood-drenched idolatry; but knowledge of God implies a valid basis for hope, for rejecting dogmatic assertions like: "There is nothing inevitable about human existence except birth and death. There are no forces, whether divine or technical, that will guarantee us a better future." 

And I've never thought of you as wanting people to "act with an urgency and passion that comprehends the grim possibilities ahead," although those possibilities are pretty grim all right.

Looking at what we can, in fact, hope to accomplish towards fending off those incoming 'grim possibilities', the best I've concluded so far is the importance of refusing to be fooled by the Powers & Principalities currently dominating human consciousness. That might prove contagious, or so I hope. But accomplishing that demands guidance from a certain divine 'force', not merely 'urgency and passion'.

Comment by Jim Wilson on 5th mo. 27, 2015 at 2:31pm

Typo Alert:  I notice I wrote 'Christ Hedges'.  I hope that is not a freudian type.  It should be 'Chris Hedges'.

Thanks,

Jim

Comment by Jim Wilson on 5th mo. 27, 2015 at 2:38pm

There, I think I've fixed it.  Ah, the eternal typo!!!

You make good points, Forrest.  I don't agree with everything that Hedges writes about progress, but I linked to it because I think it may be helpful to see how the idea of progress shaped Quaker history.  I think it had a major impact.  Fager does as well.  My tendency is to see the impact as negative, Fager's is to see it as positive.  Probably the truth lies in a less extreme take on the idea.

Jim

Comment

You need to be a member of QuakerQuaker to add comments!

Join QuakerQuaker

Support Us

Did you know that QuakerQuaker is 100% reader supported? If you think this kind of outreach and conversation is important, please support it with a monthly subscription or one-time gift.


You can also make a one-time donation.

Latest Activity

William F Rushby liked David McKay's blog post 100 Bible Verses Most Frequently Quoted By Early Quakers
9 hours ago
Matthew Callow replied to Brad Ogilvie's discussion 'Is an opulent gay wedding really progress?' in the group Sexuality/ LGBT
"Friends have a ministry of bearing witness to marriage, which we see clearly in the Gospels and…"
yesterday
Dan McCracken updated their profile
6th day (Fri)
William F Rushby replied to Howard Brod's discussion 'Why do Liberal Friends not Record Ministers or Spiritual Gifts?' in the group Liberal Quakers
6th day (Fri)
William F Rushby left a comment for David Keel
"David Keel asked: "Is that a photo of you in the car ?"  The answer is yes.  My…"
6th day (Fri)
David Keel replied to William F Rushby's discussion 'Faith: The Great Big Puzzle'
"I think a big part of that missing puzzle of a Liberal Quaker is not having the light of Christ as…"
5th day (Thu)
David Keel left a comment for William F Rushby
"Hi William,  I became interested in George Fox as a younger Christian, and William Penn…"
5th day (Thu)
William F Rushby left a comment for David Keel
"David: Would you mind telling us about yourself and why you are interested in "the early forms…"
5th day (Thu)

© 2020   Created by QuakerQuaker.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service