The Chasm between the Activist and the Contemplative


I can’t remember the name of the blog, but last year I read about a Meeting that decided to have a structured sharing between those who spoke often at Meeting for Worship and those who remained silent.  As I recall the two groups were paired and given time to express their views of Meeting for Worship.  As one might expect, those inclined to be speakers at Meeting for Worship had a lot to say, while those who inclined to silence listened politely and had a minimal response.


I believe this points to an inherent imbalance between the Activist and the Contemplative.  It is an imbalance that is difficult to see.  But it works like this:  the Activists, inspired by their causes and commitments, feel a push, even a duty, to step into a space that might be receptive to their message, and then to present that message.  Meeting for Worship, Silent Worship, is, from this perspective, an ideal setting for such messaging.


For the Contemplative, who attends Meeting for Worship in order to enter into silent prayer, it would be inappropriate to give voice to this point of view because such giving voice would obscure the silence which is the purpose of the contemplative’s presence.  And in any case, the contemplative is not really disturbed by the speaking of the Activists; so there is no reason to present a different perspective.


Thus there is an inherent imbalance; the contemplative perspective is more difficult to find or to hear because by the very nature of the contemplative life, which involves an inward turning, there is a reluctance to speak.  Inward silence, assisted by outward silence, is the reason for the contemplative’s presence at Meeting for Worship and this is best accomplished by embodying that silence.


From the perspective of the activist such a stance is almost incomprehensible.  In the 14th century classic ‘The Cloud of Unknowing’ the anonymous author writes, “Whenever anyone turns aside from the business of the world in order to give more time to prayer and meditation, others who do not share this interest will grumble.  Family and friends will speak out sharply against what they interpret as ‘idleness.’  Because they do not observe any outward activity, they assume nothing is happening.”  (Section 18, page 30, Bernard Bangley edition, published by Christian Classics)  For the activist silent prayer is a means to support more effective activity towards a goal.  For the contemplative silent prayer is the goal.  This is the chasm which separates the two.


In the 1946 edition (reprinted by Pendle Hill in 1979), of ‘A Guide to True Peace’, Howard Brinton writes in his ‘Introduction’ that the contemplative solution of turning inwards “ . . . will seem too simple to intellectuals and too inadequate to activists, the two groups that dominate our age.”  (Page ix)  I believe Brinton is here pointing to the same chasm which separates the contemplative from the activist today, and which the author of the ‘Cloud’ commented on centuries ago.


Does this means that the gap between the two is unbridgeable?  I’m not sure.  But it is my view that without the contemplative foundation the Quaker tradition will simply become an adjunct to various and sundry causes of the moment.  What is needed, I think, is some kind of vessel, some means, for holding the contemplative perspective and practice of the Quaker tradition; a vessel which can hold these teachings and practices and pass them on to others.  I’m not sure how best to do this.  Perhaps study groups specifically devoted to the contemplative perspective as found in the Quaker tradition (e.g. ‘A Guide to True Peace’), or perhaps a more monastically inclined Quaker group devoted to such faith and practice. 


In the past Quaker contemplatives could count on a culture which valued its distinctiveness in terms of speech, dress, and way of life.  And this distinctiveness served as a vessel which could hold the contemplative dimension of Quaker Faith and Practice.  With those distinctive features almost completely gone the contemplative dimension of Quaker Faith and Practice has become, to a significant extent, hidden; almost as if being a contemplative belonged with plain speech and plain dress, so that when those were given up a contemplative dimension was given up as well.


I think the first step is to recover the writings and views from the Quaker Quietists of the past; to find out what they said as opposed to modern historians’ views of what the period of Quietism means.  When I have stumbled upon this material I have found it to be amazingly articulate and clear.  They really knew what they were talking about; they knew ‘experimentally’, as they would have said.  Upon this foundation we can, perhaps, recover the ‘true peace’ which is the fountainhead of the Quaker tradition; a timeless spring of light nourishing all who awaken to its presence.


Views: 95

Comment by Stephanie Stuckwisch on 10th mo. 20, 2012 at 11:55am

Thank you for this post.

I think this is an issue that most meetings would like to avoid. From my point of view, in the later half of the 29th century, we lost out center as a listening community whose actions grew out of that listening.

Every time I serve on a clearness committee for membership, I hear people say that the testimonies and our activism drew them. No one mentions the expectant silence, ongoing revelation or the prophetic stream.

We've lost the tradition of elders, ministers and overseers who could have nurtured these new comers. Most of us only know the legalist and dominating aspect of these roles. So the testimonies have become our golden idol rather than the fruit of an I/Thou relationship with the the Spirit.

Comment by Jim Wilson on 10th mo. 21, 2012 at 9:07am

Good Morning:

You have raised an interesting point that I have not considered: that a primarily activist stance attracts more activists.  And this will result, over time, in an increasing percentage of activists.  I know of at least one person who, though attracted to the Quaker tradition, is having a very difficult time following through on that attraction.  In conversations with me she has stated that the group is just too political.  I wonder, now, how many people have silently decided to not participate, or become members, because of this.  Activists tend to see their commitments and membership inducing; but there is another side to this. 

This is not something confined to Quakers; my Catholic friends find it increasingly difficult to attend mass if the price for attending is a political diatribe disguised as a sermon.  It just seems that American religion in general is becoming more and more political/activist.  I think that is unfortunate.

Best wishes,

Thy Friend Jim


You need to be a member of QuakerQuaker to add comments!

Join QuakerQuaker

Support Us

Did you know that QuakerQuaker is 100% reader supported? If you think this kind of outreach and conversation is important, please support it with a monthly subscription or one-time gift.

You can also make a one-time donation.

Latest Activity

Hamilton Lindley updated their profile
13 hours ago
Michael H Boulton updated their profile
6th day (Fri)
Kirby Urner posted a video

"The Industry Industry Missed" (A Meme)

School of Tomorrow. Dymaxion House thread. American Transcendentalism, from Emerson to Bucky Fuller. Heuristics for Teachers (Fall 2020)
5th day (Thu)
Theodore Schmidkonz liked Kirby Urner's video
9th month 21
Kirby Urner posted a video

New England Transcendentalism: Bringing It Forward

The history of American literature includes the philosophy, and futurism, of R. Buckminster Fuller. Given our historical framework, let's give that philosoph...
9th month 20
William F Rushby replied to William F Rushby's discussion 'Recapturing Initiative for Conservative Friends'
"Wow, Marcia!  Your email is packed with issues we could discuss.  I am still laboring…"
9th month 2
Marcia P Roberts replied to William F Rushby's discussion 'Recapturing Initiative for Conservative Friends'
"I am curious to know what rituals Conservative Friends hold dear, William, when you talk about…"
9th month 2
Scott MacLeod liked Laura Rediehs's profile
8th month 26

© 2020   Created by QuakerQuaker.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service