Matthew S.'s Friends

  • Kevin-Douglas Olive
  • Micah Bales

Matthew S.'s Discussions

Military Service?

Started this discussion. Last reply by Rosemary Gould 10th month 3, 2010. 9 Replies

So, I'm in a moral quandary.I've been freelancing a bit with a news site financed by the U.S. Department of Defense, but run by a defense contractor. Next year, I tend to move to D.C., and they have…Continue

Tags: peace, military

 

Matthew S.'s Page

Latest Activity

Matthew S. commented on QuakerQuaker's video
Thumbnail

I Hear You've Become a Quaker, Pt. 1

"@ Cotswold - Ideally, yes. If you don't feel led by God, you shouldn't speak at meeting. It's very distracting (and disrespectful to the silence, I think) when people use it as a bully pulpit for political issues or a place to talk…"
3rd month 1, 2011
Matthew S. commented on Brian Martin's blog post 'My Conflict with the Peace Testimony'
"This is a quote I love from Martin Kelley:   "But for all of their contemporary centrality to Quakerism, the testimonies are only second-hand outward forms. They are not to be worshipped in and of themselves. Modern Friends come…"
12th month 11, 2010
Rosemary Gould replied to Matthew S.'s discussion 'Military Service?'
"Thank you for thanking me, Scot. I found myself praying about Matthew's questions during meeting for worship today, and what I wrote is the response that came to me."
10th month 3, 2010
scot miller replied to Matthew S.'s discussion 'Military Service?'
"Rosemary, You have the wisdom that my personality always tries to bury. Your post in response to Matthew has been the most thoughtful and productive part of may First Day. Thank you for gently suggesting a bit a clearness for our Friend, and even…"
10th month 3, 2010
Rosemary Gould replied to Matthew S.'s discussion 'Military Service?'
"Matthew, I wish you could meet with a clearness committee about this question. I know you are an isolated Friend, which makes it very difficult. But as I understand it, at least in the Hicksite tradition, true Quaker process of discernment is quite…"
10th month 3, 2010
scot miller replied to Matthew S.'s discussion 'Military Service?'
"Uhh, sorry that I might have been condescending. By your response to what I wrote, you have already made up your mind, considering your ability to justify your wishes by using the witness of so many Friends. I could have don that by suggesting you…"
10th month 3, 2010
Forrest Curo replied to Matthew S.'s discussion 'Military Service?'
"What I told you was simply how I felt about compromising with organizations with evil objectives and evil means of realizing them. I would have been perfectly okay with doing a civilian project for the same corporation. But the more I've…"
10th month 3, 2010
Matthew S. replied to Matthew S.'s discussion 'Military Service?'
"Scot, I have large qualms with your response; to me, it seems arbitrary, too broad, and a little condescending. You make presumptions about me you with no basis. Also, I don't think the "the parameters of historical Quaker belief"…"
10th month 3, 2010
Micah Bales left a comment for Matthew S.
"What are you doing in Morocco?"
9th month 30, 2010
Forrest Curo replied to Matthew S.'s discussion 'Military Service?'
"I'd been going to school while living on Aid to the Totally Demented for years, and my former wife was getting tired of poverty. I'd been starting my second year of work towards a 2nd BA in 'computer science', looking forward to…"
9th month 27, 2010
scot miller replied to Matthew S.'s discussion 'Military Service?'
"I agree that the Quaker position on taking positions related to the military in any capacity goes against our Peace Testimony. However, the fact that this is a Quaker ethic means just that. You do not have to be a Quaker, or a pacifist, to attend…"
9th month 27, 2010
Matthew S. replied to Matthew S.'s discussion 'Military Service?'
"That just seems too cut-and-dry to me. What is the military these days? Should Quakers not work with the Army Corp of Engineers to rebuild the levees in New Orleans? Or passing out food rations in Rwanda? Or installing cellphone towers in…"
9th month 18, 2010
Matthew S. replied to Forrest Curo's discussion 'Does "New Testament God" Mean Anything Different From "Old Testament God"?'
"In the way I perceive ongoing revelation, I see them as the same God, but that He only revealed parts of himself that would be accepted at the time. Matthew 19:1-12 is a good example of this. Originally, there was polygamy, but Moses came and…"
9th month 18, 2010
Matthew S. commented on QuakerQuaker's blog post 'Peggy Parsons deals with sexual harassment on the road'
"Wonderful!"
9th month 18, 2010
Matthew S. replied to Alice Bejnar's discussion 'Welcoming released prisoners in meeting/church?'
"As a journalist, I spent a long time writing and researching about religion and prisons back in 2007. The theme that always recurred was that when people were released, they were put back into the same neighborhoods, in the same situations, with no…"
9th month 16, 2010
Matthew S. replied to Rosemary Gould's discussion 'What do you do in silent worship?'
"For me, mantras and sayings never get me in the head space I need, and I prefer something visual. Mostly, I close my eyes and imagine that I am getting larger, absorbing good energy, growing upward, and sending it out again. I picture rivers of…"
9th month 16, 2010

Profile Information

About Me
A Quaker living in Morocco, feeling quite isolated from the Community :(
Website/Blog
http://americanpilgrimage.com

Comment Wall (1 comment)

You need to be a member of QuakerQuaker to add comments!

Join QuakerQuaker

At 1:15pm on 9th mo. 30, 2010, Micah Bales said…
What are you doing in Morocco?
 
 
 

Tip Jar

It takes many hours a month to sift through hundreds of websites to come up with this daily curated list of the best of the Quaker web. If you learn more about Friends and find joy and spiritual growth in the conversations these links provide, please consider supporting the ministry with a monthly subscription.

You can also make a one-time donation.

Latest Activity

Randy Oftedahl commented on Randy Oftedahl's blog post 'What Divides Us and What Unites Us'
"Thank you, Friends, for your comments.  David, I appreciate what you have to say, though…"
1 hour ago
Irene Lape posted a blog post

Daily Old Testament and Early Christian Writings: Numbers 31-32 and Origen's De Principiis: Book One - 6-7

Numbers 31 - Twelve thousand men, 1000 from each of the tribes, are sent out by Moses to attack the…See More
4 hours ago
Profile IconQuakerQuaker.org

Jon Watts: 12 Pieces of Advice for Quakers on the Internet

I have begun to hear back from Friends who read my article and who have long felt that they should… See More
18 hours ago
Matthew Hughes commented on Kevin Camp's blog post 'Confronting Mental Illness in Monthly Meetings'
"Dear Kevin – I am so pleased to see your blog and I will try and reply to it at great length…"
19 hours ago
Profile IconQuakerQuaker.org

Craig Barnett: Trusting in the Spirit

absence of conflict or an easy consensus. It is an active process of self-discipline that enables… See More
yesterday
Irene Lape posted blog posts
yesterday
James C Schultz commented on Clem Gerdelmann's blog post 'A Penchant For Praise'
"I would suggest we have to look no further than Paul's letter to the Galatians: Gal 5:22:But…"
yesterday
Doug Bennett commented on Doug Bennett's blog post 'A New Association of Friends Is Born'
"A composite answer to Jim Wilson's question from NAF folks including Margaret Fraser, Michael…"
yesterday

About QuakerQuaker

QuakerQuaker is a community of Friends exploring Primitive Christianity Revived: plain witness, ministry, beliefs. Quaker blogs, photos, videos & gatherings. Learn More.

Subscribe in a reader
Get daily emails
Facebook
iTunes / Podcast
Twitter / Twitter Quaker List

 

Advertise:

Learn about QQ Advertising

Place an Order

The QuakerQuaker Audience

Quakers

© 2013   Created by QuakerQuaker.

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service