This one is going to be controversial...

Have you noticed how even complete strangers feel free to ask your child 'And what are you having for Christmas?'. I'm a first time mum, and I've never encountered this really grates, for lots of reasons.

Firstly, I believe that Christmas is about more than buying gifts. Secondly, I feel it encourages children to compete with each other...finally, I am aware that in a recession there will be lots of parents out there who are struggling to make ends meet anyway, and can do without additional pressure.

This morning I dropped my three year old off at nursery and overheard one of the nursery assistants having just this conversation with her group. I found myself speaking to the manager and saying that the Christmas story was actually about homeless people and an expectant mum looking for shelter. I said I was a Quaker and that I didnt' think it was okay to be asking children such questions, especially not in a recession.

It felt like I was taking a big risk, tackling this one, and I'm sure some people weren't pleased. Still, I followed my heart.


Views: 74

Reply to This

Replies to This Discussion

'And what are you having for Christmas?'

The question in its context implies that children can know with some confidence what they're getting for Christmas. Is this because parents/guardians &c. tell them in advance what they plan to give? I doubt it. Does it mean that it's taken for granted in this circle that children ask for particular presents and are confident they will get what they ask for? Much more likely.

As a child I would have found the question bizarre. It was understood in my family that presents were surprises, and that while you could request a particular present there was no guarantee that you would get it. This was in 1970s Britain, and I don't remember feeling that my family was unusual in this respect.

I suppose the new system has the 'advantage' that it facilitates the exploitation of parents by big business through pester power, and the exploitation of children as unpaid company sales staff.

Not only is Christmas not, from a Christian point of view, primarily about gift-giving, but for the Christian the giving of gifts is something that should be done freely out of love, not in response to emotional blackmail.

I don't think our daughter (three years and two months) would understand the question, as she doesn't seem to remember much of last Christmas. She's fascinated by Christmas trees but doesn't seem to know what they are. I'm not that keen to explain, as I'd like it all to be a surprise, and I want to keep the focus on the Christ child and not on the usurper with the beard and red coat.

The holy family weren't technically homeless, by the way, just travelling and caught out by overbooking. But they did become refugees when they had to flee from Herod into Egypt. See excellent post here:

I think you were right to follow your heart. And it's good to hear from another British blogger on QuakerQuaker.
Sanna speaks my mind: "I think more people agree with thee than thee feels." And part of offering up a witness does indeed have to do with going against the grain and risk being "counter cultural."

When someone asked me what I was getting for Chrismtas when I was a child, I had an easy answer: "I don't celebrate Christmas: I'm Jewish." Now it's not so easy, since I'm not a child, I don't practice any form of Judaism, and I identify as Quaker. But I've been very open this year about my plans for this year:

My partner and I are "sponsoring" a couple of households in the metro area that can't afford presents for one another, so we do some of their shopping for them, anonymously. Often what the families ask for are warm clothes or a few frying pans. This year, I'm also buying a teenager a dictionary and a hard-backed Harry Potter book. And we're keeping our home decorations simple--no tree, no garland. A natural wreath for the door and a few smaller boughs in the house.

It feels nice to shed the excess and focus instead on giving to needy individuals and families. And it feels nice to not feel so alone in that anymore.

Liz Opp, The Good Raised Up
I hate to beat the horse again, especially since Christmas has come and gone, but I thought I'd add in what my intentional community did for Christmas this year. We had a "secret Santa" kind of thing going, except the stipulation was that we couldn't spend a single penny on our gift(s). After a wonderful dinner of sweets and finger foods, we all grabbed mugs of homemade eggnog and crammed into the common room to open gifts. What followed was the most beautiful, warm, loving, and generous gift-giving I have ever witnessed. Johanna gave me an IOU for a luxurious back massage (she's trained!). Joe wrote Tyler a song. I made Ashley a wreath out of greens and berries I'd gathered, with a big bow made out of one of my old shirts. Andrea gave Chrissie a beautifully hand-painted Advent calendar. Maddy made Ben a yarn pom-pom for his hat. Abby tried her hand at painting some of her favorite places for Adria. Some gifts came out nicer than others, of course (I think, for example, of Chrissie's failed attempt at dinosaur-shaped cookies for Eli), but they were all so sweet and personal that it didn't matter. Everyone had put time and love into their gifts, and because it was a $0 gift-exchange, all of the gifts were handmade, foraged, or secondhand.

I love Liz's way of celebrating Christmas, and it seems to me that $0 gift-giving could also accompany a beautifully centered, Quaker Christmas. It would sidestep all the commercialism and wastefulness and focus instead on using our own creativity and skills (really, the gifts that God has given us) while also strengthening human relationships.

I don't have kids, but I remember when I was little and made gifts for my parents out of randomness. Because I was too young for an allowance, all my gifts had to be free. Our teachers knew this, of course, so they often had us take out the craft supplies to make gifts that didn't cost us anything. In fact, I fondly remember when my pre-school class went out to the vacant lot behind the school and picked flowers/weeds for Mother's Day. Jesus wants us to be like little children, right? So, maybe we can return to that mode of gift-giving, where we're not asked "what are you getting?" but "what did you make your mommy?" Let's all get out the dried macaroni and construction paper! ;)

Reply to Discussion


Support Us

Did you know that QuakerQuaker is 100% reader supported? If you think this kind of outreach and conversation is important, please support it with a monthly subscription or one-time gift.

You can also make a one-time donation.

Latest Activity

Theodore Schmidkonz liked Kirby Urner's video
9 hours ago
Kirby Urner posted a video

New England Transcendentalism: Bringing It Forward

The history of American literature includes the philosophy, and futurism, of R. Buckminster Fuller. Given our historical framework, let's give that philosoph...
William F Rushby replied to William F Rushby's discussion 'Recapturing Initiative for Conservative Friends'
"Wow, Marcia!  Your email is packed with issues we could discuss.  I am still laboring…"
9th month 2
Marcia P Roberts replied to William F Rushby's discussion 'Recapturing Initiative for Conservative Friends'
"I am curious to know what rituals Conservative Friends hold dear, William, when you talk about…"
9th month 2
Scott MacLeod liked Laura Rediehs's profile
8th month 26
William F Rushby replied to William F Rushby's discussion 'Recapturing Initiative for Conservative Friends'
8th month 23
Keith Saylor replied to William F Rushby's discussion 'Recapturing Initiative for Conservative Friends'
""The evidence suggests that Friends need the counsel of one another to implement their…"
8th month 23
William F Rushby replied to William F Rushby's discussion 'Recapturing Initiative for Conservative Friends'
"Howard, I think you would be above such stuff!"
8th month 22

© 2020   Created by QuakerQuaker.   Powered by

Badges  |  Report an Issue  |  Terms of Service